Oscar’s Pizza Joint
Price: $12.00 for a 12-inch custom pizza with two toppings
Presentation: Oscar’s pizza looks like a pizza. That’s it. There’s a little bit of garnishing around the crust, but it looks like what anyone would expect from a pizza
Taste: With a crispy crust, it’s one of Oscar’s high points. The toppings are plentiful but average. Overall, it’s a good pie, but there’s nothing that sets it above everything else.
Rating: 3 out of 5 stars
Schlittz & Giggles
Price: $16.99 for The Big Pepperoni
Presentation: The pie is massive. It’s 18 inches with big slices. While it’s a bit greasy, the size more than makes up for it.
Taste: Schlittz’s pie is great. The crust is thin and delicious and the toppings are superb. It’s an amazing, huge, greasy slice of pizza.
Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars
Red Zeppelin
Price: $11.95 for a 10-inch Margherita pizza
Presentation: Red Zeppelin’s pizza looks the most gourmet. The sauce comes is very visible with large blotches of mozzarella and a drizzle of pesto sauce
Taste: The crust was crunchy, yet it was a bit tough to bite. The toppings are great and add a strong flavor. It’s a unique and overlooked pizza.
Rating: 3.5 out of 5
Mellow Mushroom
Price:$11.29 for a 10-inch Mighty Meaty Pizza
Presentation: The toppings are everywhere and it’s fluffy crust is very appealing to the eye.
Taste: Even with the toppings covering much of the pizza, none of the flavors dominate any other. In one bite, you can taste everything, from the sausage to the bacon to the cheese. There’s a reason Mellow Mushroom is loved so much.
Rating: 4 out of 5

Gallery • 3 Photos

Richard Redmann

Schlittz and Giggles pepperoni pizza