The series finale gave us the perfect goodbye, but the beauty of streaming services is you can always start over. Here’s my top picks from each season of “Brooklyn Nine-Nine.”
“The Pontiac Bandit” Season 1, Episode 12
This episode sets up Jake’s series-long frenemy-ship with Doug Judy, played by Craig Robinson, also known for playing Darryl on “The Office.” Doug and Jake Peralta (Andy Samberg) go on several adventures right down to the final season. Any episode with an appearance by the infamous Doug Judy is sure to be a double-crossing, action-packed, karaoke-filled time.
“The Beach House” Season 2 Episode 12
The squad takes a break, traveling to Charles Boyle’s (Joe Lo Truglio) beach house in the middle of the winter. The opening scene of this episode is a fan favorite. After the opening credits, Jake learns Holt (Andre Braugher) had never been invited to an out-of-the-office event and invites him to join the team. The group has to balance their partying personalities — we’re looking at you, fanny pack wearing Vacation Terry — with Holt’s more classical hobbies.
“Yippie Kayak” Season 3, Episode 10
A real-life “Die Hard” situation, or so Bruce Willis fanatic Peralta pretends. While last-minute Christmas shopping, Peralta, Boyle and Gina Linetti (Chelsea Peretti) get caught in a hostage situation in a department store robbery. If you’re a fan of the 1988 action thriller, you’ll have a lot of fun watching this reference-packed episode.
“Cop Con” Season 4, Episode 17
The Nine-Nine heads to Cop-Con, the annual tri-state convention. While the squad tries to throw a secret party, Captain Holt is preparing for an important presentation and seriously considering adding color to his PowerPoint slides. Even the subplots are memorable, including Boyle’s robot best friend battle and a love interest for Scully (Joel McKinnon Miller).
“HalloVeen” Season 5, Episode 4
You can’t go wrong watching any “Halloween heist” episode. They’re all great, but the one that stands out is “HalloVeen.” Things get serious when Captain Holt involves his fluffy boy, a Corgi named Cheddar. The episode also involves some special moments between Peralta and Amy Santiago (Melissa Fumero). Like they say, all’s fair in love and Halloween heists.
“Suicide Squad” Season 6, Episode 18
“The enemy of my enemy is my friend.” Three recurring antagonists return in the season six finale, but this time, they’re working with the squad to eliminate Commissioner John Kelly (Phil Reeves). Holt’s rival Madeline Wuntch (Kyra Sedgwick) and Captain C.J. Stentley (Ken Marino) team up with Allstate’s “mayhem like me” commercial star, Dean Winters. Though Winters is better known as “The Vulture” on Brooklyn Nine-Nine, the premise stands, his character brings mayhem wherever he goes.
“Ding Dong” Season 7, Episode 7
After a series-long battle of wits and dryly delivered comebacks, the rivalry between Holt and Wuntch comes to a close in this season seven episode. Holt’s insults to Wuntch were the best they’d ever been. If you ask me, this was the perfect goodbye before the perfect goodbye.
“The Lake House” Season 8, Episode 2
Other than the final episode, the best pick out of the last season is episode two, “The Lake House.” Similar to “The Beach House” in season two, the squad takes a group vacation to Holt’s so-named lake house. It doesn’t take Peralta long to turn the relaxing vacation into a parent-trap style mission involving bird watching with Holt and his husband Cozner (Marc Evan Jackson).
The best episode from each season of ‘Brooklyn Nine-Nine’
By Ava Borskey | @iamavab
September 21, 2021