Fred Fellner, Facility Services assistant director for landscape services, stood in the shade of several live oak trees across from Parker Coliseum on South Stadium Road, combing his hand through his hair while his radio crackled with work crews’ reports. Branches twisted and torn from trees scatter the ground, and Fellner’s men are still in the early stages of removing the dying debris and restoring the campus landscape, torn by Hurricane Gustav’s landfall Monday.”I don’t see any particular reason that limb would fail,” said Fellner, pointing at a live oak limb laying on the ground, nearly 10 years long and branching out another five. “A lot of the times the limbs you see fail will have some pre-existing weakness. In other cases, you might just have such significant wind in an area that it would just take out limbs no matter what. We have a complete combination of these kinds of failures.”Around 100 on-campus trees fell during Gustav’s winds, 50 being “larger” in size — 12 to 36 inch DBH, or diameter at breast height, said Fellner. Breast height is 4.6 feet above ground on a tree’s trunk, according to a USDA Forrest Service Web site.”There is a considerable amount of damage,” Fellner said Thursday afternoon. “Certainly it will be 80 to 100 hours of labor at our current rate before we can really see how much is done and get an idea of how much more is to be done.The University’s “stately oaks,” immortalized in the alma mater for shading “inspiring halls,” were largely spared. Of these 12,000 live oaks on campus, 10 percent — maybe more — have at least some slight damage, said Fellner. Among the most trees damaged are water oaks, maples, sycamores, cow oaks and silver maples.The only “stately oak” to die at Gustav’s illusive mercy toppled behind Julian Miller Hall, where the University’s “urban forest” environment collected its toll. The tree had a weak “crotch” or “branch” structure, where limbs come together compounded by limited foot space to grow, sandwiched between Tower Drive and a parking lot, said Fellner.Piles of fallen brush rest under most live oak trees, but such damage is “not considerable,” said Fellner, as live oaks are “designed to handle it.” Inactive buds in these trees burst into limbs from reserve power and hormonal activities as sunlight reaches areas damaged by weather, part of the trees natural growth process.Fellner said 145 people engaged in “wood waste vegetative removal” on campus Thursday. His department has 80 employees, although only 52 could make it to campus as others dealt with Gustav-related personal issues. Fellner also directs 50 inmates in the cleanup process and a nine-man contracted arbor crew running one chipper and two loaders.”Several hundreds of tons” of debris will be collected, loaded onto trailers and ferried off campus.”We’ll chip it and grind it and make into mulch and bring it back to campus,” Fellner said. “We actually reuse all of it.”The process is divided into three stages — safety and hazard reduction, physical clean up and replacement and long term care.Fellner began the first stage Tuesday morning. He aims to have the campus safe when classes resume Monday and clean by the time tailgaters flood the campus for the football team’s Sept. 13 game against North Texas — both “reasonable goals” in his mind.Gustav cleanup simply on Fellner’s end will cost “well into six figures” — a bulk paying for labor — and will be complete quicker than repairs for roof or other structural damages.Fellner spent Thursday identifying trees with damage posing safety issues — limbs hanging over sidewalks or blocking traffic — with an forester consultant. His crews are removing these threats.”We’re definitely going to be working too next week to complete this entire cleanup process,” said Fellner.After completing cleanup, Fellner will repopulate the campus with 200 to 250 specimen trees, two to five inches in diameter. Replacement trees will likely be of the same species and planted in similar areas as lost ones.”We don’t want to just give up trees,” Fellner said. “We want to be able to plant a tree for a tree or maybe a couple of trees for a trees.”The repopulating process may cast $40,000 to $50,000 — $150-200 per specimen tree, which is doubled for labor costs and again doubled for estimating. These cost will be passed to the state.The large number of on-campus trees creates the “urban forest,” and limitations come with the landscape. These trees must cope with stress factors a normal forest doen’t experience —vehicle and pedestrian traffic, building construction and concrete removal.This environment lead a red oak in front of Middleton Library in the Quad to “pancake,” or have its roots ripped through the ground, toppling over, Fellner said.”The Quad is a very harsh environment,” Fellner said. “There is a lot of competition in there for nutrients and for light and for moisture. That tree in the long run was being out competed by the live oak trees. Even though it looked healthy, the root structure had a lot of fungal rot in it.”The live oaks, which Fellner describes as a “green infrastructure,” were planted mostly between 1930 and 1940. Annually, Fellner said around 50 new live oaks are planted on campus, mostly in areas where campus is expanding, such as new buildings or parking lots and South Campus on GSRI Road.Around 250 live oak trees are endowed through the LSU Foundation. Half the donated funds are in a general endowment fund while the other half are in an account used in “normal circumstances” including mulching, lightning protection, bracing and cabling, health care and fertilization. No endowment money is being used during the cleanup or repopulation of trees damaged during Gustav, said Fellner.Fellner is identifying endowed trees with damage to communicate to the LSU Foundation so donors may be notified of their tree’s condition. Ten years ago, the University’s live oaks were conservatively appraised at $36 million. Today, these trees are easily worth more than $50 million, Fellner said.Gustav’s damage did not affect the live oaks’ value, Fellner said. A basic formula is used in forestry consulting to appraise trees, and apart from the one toppled live oak, none were impacted in a way influencing the formula’s outcome.”They have really grown to the point where they really define the landscape,” Fellner said. “They define the buildings — the arching of the limbs and the arching of the buildings themselves all speak to that renaissance architecture that we have here. They’re very enduring, and they’re a multi-generational tree. There is something about us appreciating something that outlives us, and I think everybody kind of taps into that. They’re iconic. They’re a symbol of the University, and they’re a symbol of the part of the country we live in. Try to imagine LSU without its oaks.”
On-campus trees extensively damaged
By Nicholas Persac
News Editor
News Editor
September 4, 2008